I have learned in recent weeks there is a significant difference between my Mavic 3 Pro drone and the Mavic 3 Enterprise. The enterprise edition comes with a different controller that can do automated mission planning, among other things. The enterprise model also supports an RTK module which provides very precise positioning needed by engineers and surveyors. The RTK module is an add-on, $890 from the reputable dealers and less on eBay. That additional cost is in addition to the $1,700 price difference between the similarly-named drone models.
But what about using the Pro version for a roof inspection? Centimeter accuracy isn't needed just to get pictures of a roof, right? One of the job aggregators that I patronize keeps sending me such missions, so I took one and flew it a couple of days ago. It was a small office building with a gently-sloping roof 20-23 feet above the ground. I downloaded the KML map from the company, imported it into web-based Litchi Hub, set the parameters for ortho and oblique missions, and exported the two KMZ files. (Ortho is the camera pointing straight down; oblique is at a downward angle of 45 degrees.) Then I followed the laborious procedure of:
- Setting up two dummy waypoint missions on the Mavic controller.
- Using Windows Explorer, copying the KMZ files to the controller's SD card.
- Using the controller, copying the KMZ files from the SD card to the folders on the controller's internal storage containing the dummy missions. This couldn't be done in Windows Explorer because it does not see the file structure of the internal storage.
- Copying the names of the dummy files, then deleting them.
- Renaming the new files with the names of the deleted dummy files.
With an enterprise drone and controller with integrated missions planning, you avoid all of this dummy file nonsense.
But despite being cumbersome, it works. I also uploaded the missions to my new Mini Pro 5, which is a somewhat easier process. It combines the final four steps into a few clicks. I flew the missions first with the Mini, but quickly realized that it does not have the processing power of the Mavic and couldn't take the photos as fast as was needed. Despite being easier to program, the Mini will not be my mapping drone. It did come in handy when I wanted to measure the height of a tower that was very close to the flight path. Without using any Mavic battery, I was able to determine that the top was about 10 feet below the planned oblique flight (58 feet) and well below the ortho flight (115 feet). Doing initial on-site scouting and saving the Mavic's battery may be the Mini's role.
I flew both missions with the Mavic at a global speed of only 2 mph, but found that the drone accelerated to 33 mph when going from one leg to another, throwing it out of alignment for the first couple shots of the next leg. I reshot the ortho mission after slowing travel between all 28 waypoints down to the global speed and completed that with no problem. I had used up two batteries and was down to my third and last. I found a power outlet on the building and plugged in the charger, just in case.
I reshot the oblique mission at the slower global speed and ran out of battery power. Compared to the ortho mission, it had a much longer distance to travel and 124 waypoints. I thought I had enough to just make it, but I came up two waypoints short. With the meter showing 7%, 2.5 minutes and flashing red, the drone said it was going to land "immediately" and I had to quickly steer it from over the roof to a safe landing area. It wasn't quite Neil Armstrong avoiding a lunar boulder field, but it was more exciting than I had planned. By then the other battery was recharged to 93%, and I was able to reshoot the mission in its entirety with no problem at a global speed of 4.7 mph. Litchi Hub does suggest a drone speed based on all the parameters you feed it, and its suggestions were 7.5 for the oblique and over 10 for the ortho. I had lower numbers in there because I needed them for the Mini, and that got me into trouble.
Another fun fact I found when researching differences is that the Enterprise model has a mechanical shutter, which is preferable for missions like this versus the Pro drone's electronic shutter. The Pro was able to snap decent images at 4.7 mph without detectable smearing that might have been evident at a faster flying speed or slower shutter speed. Litchi Hub suggests a speed based on all the inputs, 7.5-10 mph depending on the different parameters, and I'll have to see if those are usable for the Mavic.
The point of this excruciating detail is that the Mavic 3 Pro is not optimal for automated roof inspection flights, and it took me a while to figure out some of the settings, but it can be done. The job aggregator accepted my files, and there are two more mapping jobs I can accept from them. This aggregator is weird in that they put a job out at a low price, then raise it every day or so for the next few weeks until someone takes it or they reach their limit and give up. I figure I'm a week away from taking the two jobs, if they are still available.
Perhaps the best part about taking these missions is I don't have to merge the images. Someone else does all of that. I did a quick merge of the ortho images in Photoshop and it did a truly awful job. So I will show just one unmerged, cropped image from the oblique mission that may be revealing a couple of problem areas on the roof.
Here's that same section of roof from the ortho image. It was shot from a higher altitude, thus the smaller apparent size.
Conclusions:
- It is possible to do automated ortho and oblique waypoint missions without spending extra for the Enterprise drone/controller, but the cheap way has its challenges and limitations.
- There is a point where greater precision of the Enterprise software and hardware are needed. I'm not ready to take that plunge because my volume of work does not justify it.
- I did take the plunge of ordering a fourth Mavic battery. Having the drone demanding to land immediately helped drive that decision. It's not a light decision because these batteries cost more than $150 from reputable dealers.
- Litchi Hub (free) allows you to split a mission into separate KMZ files if it is too big to fly on one battery. I could have split the oblique mission into two and life would have been less tense.


No comments:
Post a Comment